Tuesday, November 26, 2013

CRIMINAL MINDS Season 9 - 909. Strange Fuit - Review

Southern trees bear a strange fruit,
Blood on the leaves and blood at the root,
Black bodies swinging in the southern breeze,
Strange fruit hanging from the poplar trees.

Normally, I watch an episode that I'm reviewing at least twice, sometimes 3 or 4 times. But this one was so powerful, I watched it only once before writing all of this. (Don't worry, Ms. Barrois – I am going to go watch it again and again, after I post my comments.)  For this review, I'm going to go through it primarily by character, because as much as the plot and the editing were superb (and I will comment on those as well), what remains with me most is the portrait of each individual that was highlighted by Janine Sherman Barrois' excellent script and Constantine Makris' expert direction.

LYLE JOHNSON, the son (Seth Gilliam)
Seeing his father kill someone when he was a 5 year old child, well that would certainly explain why he had so many behavioral problems throughout his life.  (And I just have to insert this random shallow comment: his gait when he tries to run away from Hotch after he and his father come home to a yard full of law enforcement…well, it looked goofy, like a Looney Tunes cartoon. It distracted me. But that was probably just me.)  Whatever you thought of Lyle's behavior and motivations (and his abrupt collapse from enraged suspect to crying penitent after seeing his murdered girlfriend's photo left me a bit disoriented) you must admit that Seth Gilliam's performance was gripping.

The younger male Johnson generated an active sense of discomfort and frustration in this viewer, watching his antagonistic “yessuh” antics during his interrogation scenes with Hotch, who is possibly the whitest white man in America (culturally speaking). Why won't Lyle just answer the questions and clear himself?? But then, I'm not a black man, so I've never had to deal with the sidelong glances and “random” stop and frisks and other casual incidents that could create such explosive anger in a man, innocent or not. As the episode's title from the Billie Holiday song promises, this story is inextricably bound up in race and all of the reasons someone once produced a t-shirt for sale that read, “No, white lady, I DON'T want your purse.”

“This country is not kind to young black men.”
TINA JOHNSON, the mother ( L. Scott Caldwell)
Ms. Caldwell's performance was spot on as a woman living in denial. Immersed in decorating her home, and burying her disappointment over having a boy (her conversation / interrogation with Morgan was memorable indeed!) she seemed the epitome of a gentle southern mother determinedly ignoring her son's troubled behavior and her husband's castration. (Who WAS Lyle's father anyway?? I suppose that's not really important to the plot, but still…I wanna know!)

My, what an ambiguous look you have . . . (a\k\a it's all in the eyes)
CHARLES JOHNSON, the father (Glynn Turman)
1st warning sign: The Johnsons are described as salt of the earth.
2nd warning sign: …involved with the Neighborhood Watch,
3rd warning sign: …and have lived there for 35 YEARS!
4th warning sign: “Tina wanted a pool but we knew we’d never have time to use it.” Oh really? We did, did we?

Yes, here we come to the TRUE masterpiece (and I use this word deliberately) of this episode: Glynn Turman's performance was... words truly fail me!   Much of the success or failure of STRANGE FRUIT rested upon his shoulders and he bore the load without breaking a sweat. Transforming from an apparently stern but warm father to a controlled serial killer filled with hate…WOW.  The fact that I am not writing much about Mr. Turman is a case of "less is more": nothing I say can really compare to his cobra-and-mongoose dance with Rossi, which I plan to watch repeatedly.

Yep, looking YOURSELF in the eye is always the hardest test, isn't it?

SSA DAVID ROSSI (Joe Mantegna)
Joe Mantegna's acting during his scenes with the not-so UnSub (but that's okay, it's a duel here, not a hunt) was stellar! Superb! Subtle! Pick an “S” superlative! His scenes rose to the Clarice-and-Hannibal level of SILENCE OF THE LAMBS.  Our beloved Rossi, sharing a shameful period of his youth, left me hoping right until the bathroom scene that it was merely an embellishment to taunt the suspect, as he did in THE RECKONER.  His look of self-disgust in the men's room said it all. Alas.

I thought that Morgan's self-righteous reaction to Rossi afterward didn't take into account the era (how many decades ago? four? five?) and the age: sure Derek was picked upon as a sapling in Chicago, but there was unlikely to be a white kid nearby that his classmates would torment in addition to him.

I liked his interplay with Hotch, where the seasoned interrogator explains his technique to the expert administrator who's seeking to learn about field work.  It provides insight for the audience (“Oh, so he WANTS to get him mad!”) about both the delicate balance of a BAU agent's interrogation, and the new Section Chief's seemingly genuine desire to learn. More Esai Morales please!

In terms of his archly alluded to “assignment” with J.J., just as with The Replicator last season, the hints and teases leave me cold, as does the post-DoD J.J.  Actually, an affair between Cruz and J.J., though possibly tawdry, would be more interesting than whatever-this-is, since the team’s constant travelling and long hours are not kind to marriages.

PLOT, EDITING, and all that other GOOD STUFF
The interrogation flow, between the BAU and all 3 Johnsons, was masterful.  Having a skilled veteran director such as Constantine Makris, whom I first noticed as a cinematographer on the original LAW & ORDER, definitely paid off.  He was able to keep the tightly plotted events flowing smoothly, while at the same time eliciting riveting performances from his three leads AND the regulars. Even the “introducing the dead bodies” couple before the opening credits acquitted themselves quite well.

Having never seen a shooting script, I am not quite sure how much of the brilliant editing (revealing key plot/profiling details) throughout STRANGE FRUIT is due to the director or the writer, so I am going to split the difference and say they were BOTH awesome.

Rarely have I noticed such pointed commentary about racism in a CM episode*, but I think confronting the elephant in the room makes this a stronger rather than a weaker episode.  [Aside from Morgan's hilarious wisecrack in A REAL RAIN  about a white serial killer being able to get a cab before a black man -- “Well, he got picked up in the pouring rain by a New York cabbie, so we definitely know he's not a brother” -- it seems to me CM rarely tackles race on a sustained basis.] But as Hotch pointed out in NATURAL BORN KILLER, horrific abuse doesn't always create a serial killer.  However, it does helpfully provide endless fodder for future UnSubs.

Yes indeed, Season 9 is definitely harkening back to classic CRIMINAL MINDS, and improving on it in this case: I despised the flamboyant theatrics of MASTERPIECE, but THIS episode provides a worthy cat and mouse dance, akin to SOUL MATES. After the disappointment of Season 8 (where I seriously considered giving up on the series) this fan is as pleased as punch! Bravo, Janine!



  1. "I thought that Morgan's self-righteous reaction to Rossi afterward didn't take into account the era"

    Well what a surprise, someone here ragging on Morgan!

    Morgan had every right to feel upset to find out what his friend had done... regardless of the era... like that somehow makes it ok????? So let's just forget everything that's gone on in history, all the wrong doings, because 'it was a different era'.... So no one is allowed to feel upset or aggrieved for any of that, and if you do, you're 'self-righteous'. That's just wrong!
    And bringing it back to Criminal Minds, none of this means Morgan doesn't like Rossi or that Rossi is a bad person, but to be friends with someone, does not mean you have to agree with or condone everything they have done in their past. Morgan is allowed to feel how he feels.... may be the writer of the episode wanted to convey that feeling herself!

  2. Rossi himself no longer agreed with or condoned his actions of decades ago. He is deeply ashamed and filled with regret for what he had done. We have not forgotten everything that’s gone on in history, all the wrongdoings of a different era. Hate and fear will always exist in society but changes have been made. I also got the feeling that Morgan overreacted because Morgan knows that Rossi the adult would never act with prejudice.

  3. No surprise a Hotch fan on here agrees with the Morgan ragging.

    Why is this guy not allowed to have feelings or emotion? Just think about what you're saying

  4. I don’t know how being a Hotch fan correlates to Morgan ragging. Feeling that Morgan overreacted isn’t ragging on him. I love Morgan. And I can do ragging. Morgan is allowed to have feelings and emotions, but there should have been some acknowledgement that Morgan knows that the adult Rossi is not the adolescent Rossi.


Respectful opinions, and constructive disagreement is welcomed, but insulting/foul-mouthed, malicious, or just plain disrespectful comments towards anyone are not, and will be removed.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.